Dear CAIR:
I know virtually nothing about Islam. When events such as the recent attacks in Mumbai occur, I look to experts such as you for help in interpreting them.
Though unable to find a copy of your statement on the attacks, I have read excerpts from it. And while I'm glad that you consider the attacks to be "senseless and inexcusable acts of violence against innocent civilians," there are certain declarations from you that I'm still waiting to hear:
That the attacks are a crime against Islam and a sin against Allah;
That unless they sincerely repent their actions, the attackers will spend eternity in Hell;
That any Muslim who approves of the attacks likewise commits a crime against Islam and a sin against Allah;
That any imam who expresses approval of the attacks should be removed from his position and replaced with one who disapproves of them.
I reiterate that I know virtually nothing about Islam. Much of what little I do know about Islam, I've learned from you. Here's what I'm learning from your silence on the matters I raise above:
That the attacks are permitted in Islam and sanctioned by Allah;
That the attackers will spend eternity in Paradise;
That any Muslim who approves of the attacks is behaving properly according to Islam;
That any imam who expresses approval of the attacks is behaving properly according to Islam and should retain his place.
I hope that I've misunderstood you, and that soon I'll see your spokesmen on television denouncing as betrayers of Islam all who participated in the bombings and all who support them. If I'm to be honest, however, I must confess that I expect you to offer no such condemnations. I expect instead more blather such as "American Muslims stand with our fellow citizens of all faith in repudiating acts of terror wherever they take place and whomever they target."
Both in what you state and in what you don't, you teach me a great deal. Here's what you teach me now: Islam condones mass murder. I see no other reasonable inference from what words you've chosen to omit.
It's an uncomfortable lesson, one that shows the world to be more frightening and perilous than a peaceable man would wish. I thank you for it nonetheless, and I promise to take it to heart.